We love steak, and Prime 4640 was top notch. Truly “prime” steaks, great wine selection, and an amazing service oriented staff. Kudos to Carol for running such a fine restaurant.

PhillyRod, OpenTable

Have never had anything but exceptional service with food that deserves 10 stars. Can’t be more pleased!

Dave, OpenTable

We had know high expectations – although the reviews were very good. Service was phenomenal – Paegan was an absolute delight and as we shared with the owner – a real asset to the restaurant. We would go back just to spend time chatting with her and enjoying her excellent service. The food – was also spectacular and paced nicely. I had crab cakes that were 100% lump crab meat and my companion enjoyed a perfectly cooked steak. The portions were more than sufficient but too good to leave even a bite behind.


This restaurant had a great personality, specifically because of our extra fun waiter, Brentley! The atmosphere was very nice and comfortable and the food was very good, but all I can remember is that extra fun waiter and how much fun he made sure we had as we were celebrating our friends birthdays. The wine was good and I remember that the appetizers were great, I had the braised wagyu beef cheek ravioli, black truffle and parsley butter, cipollini onions that were just perfect. 

Lovenlife, OpenTable

We enjoyed our first dinner in this new Wmsbg restaurant immensely. Food was fabulous – much more than we expected. Loved that they feature no corkage fee on Sunday evenings for wine that the customer brings in. Great idea. Recommend it to anyone. Price is well worth it. Expensive but worthy every penny. It was our wedding anniversary and we received a free FABULOUS dessert too. WOW!

greatplace, OpenTable

We were greeted by one of the owners in a very friendly, welcoming manner, and she came by to chat later. This was not the standard forced table visit, she was very personable. We were very pleased by the wine, beer, and menu choices. Our waiter, Jay, promised my husband that the bone-in ribeye was going to be the best steak he had ever had. It was delicious – seared on the outside and perfectly cooked to temperature. My husband agreed that the steak was very possibly the best ever (We have had some great ones). My filet was perfect as well. The restaurant was not busy and we sincerely hope that we just caught it at a slower time, because we want them to succeed! We will definitely be back and have already recommended it to several people.

OpenTable Diner

Prime46Forty has the best food in Williamsburg – no contest. The preparation and presentation is artful, and the service is attentive and hospitable.

Lucky, OpenTable

Prime 46forty is truly a find in Williamsburg. After eating for a week in NYC I didn’t think we’d be able to match up to the excellent food that abounds in New York. But Prime 46forty is a place that can hold its own against any great restaurant. The food is inventive and delicious. The service was friendly but respectful. The owner is named Carol and she is doing something wonderful by opening a restaurant of such high quality in every department. The decor is really upbeat, modern , and fun. Go there.. it’s worth every penny.

OpenTable Diner

Though we are “locals”, this was our first experience at Prime46forty and we are already looking forward to the next meal here! We have traveled for years and dined in some pretty spectacular places, but this restaurant is as good if not better than the BEST. The menu is extensive, and while not “cheap eats”, you definitely get excellent value, creativity, and quality. The ambiance is modern and chic, but relaxed and welcoming. The bar is taken to a whole new level with Alannah – a true mixologist. We enjoyed visiting with our server, Rick, whose enthusiastic advice on food was excellent. It is evident that the people here are working in harmony and enjoy what they do. We spent 3 hours savoring each fantastic taste of our evening and did not want it to end. From the cocktails to appetizers to entrees to desserts – this restaurant is something special!

Nonnie6, TripAdvisor

We’ve been to Prime 46 Forty several times and have had a great experience every time. The food is exceptional, the service is always great, and the jazz on Saturday night is just an added bonus.

Rewards Network Member

Read or Write Reviews:

Screen Shot 2013-09-29 at 7.27.28 PM                    Urban Spoon  Yelp copy  Facebook  Trip Advisor copy